Sports Card Tax Tracking: What Collectors Need to Know
Disclaimer up front: This is not tax advice. I’m going to share general information about how card sales and taxes work, but your situation is different from everyone else’s. Talk to a CPA or tax professional before making any decisions about your specific taxes.
Now that that’s out of the way — let’s talk about the part of the hobby nobody wants to think about.
Reviewed July 2026. Tax rules change — verify current thresholds with the IRS/CRA or your accountant.
When Does Selling Cards Become Taxable?
If you’re in the US, the federal reporting threshold is gross sales of more than $20,000 and more than 200 transactions in a calendar year. Cross both numbers and platforms like eBay, Mercari, and COMC are required to send you a 1099-K form. Some states set their own, lower thresholds, so depending on where you live you could still get a 1099-K well under the federal number — check the IRS’s 1099-K page for the rules that apply to you.
Here’s the part that trips people up: not getting a 1099-K does not mean you owe no tax. The form is just a reporting trigger — you owe tax on your actual profit whether or not a form ever shows up. And when a 1099-K does arrive, remember it reports gross sales, not profit. If you sold $2,000 worth of cards but spent $1,800 buying them plus fees and shipping, your actual taxable income might only be $200. Or less. But you need records to prove that.
In Canada, the rules are a little different. There’s no fixed dollar threshold. The CRA looks at whether you have a “profit motive” and whether your selling activity looks more like a business than a hobby. Flipping cards regularly for profit? That’s probably business income. Selling a few doubles from your PC to fund a new hobby box? Probably not. The line is blurry and that’s exactly why you should talk to a professional.
What You Should Be Tracking
Whether you’re required to file or not, tracking your card transactions is just smart. Here’s what to record for every purchase and every sale:
When you buy:
- What card you bought (player, year, set, parallel, card number)
- Purchase price (including shipping)
- Date of purchase
- Where you bought it (eBay, LCS, card show, Facebook group)
When you sell:
- Sale price
- Platform fees (eBay takes ~13%, Mercari takes 10%, etc.)
- Shipping cost
- Date of sale
The fees matter more than most people realize. You sell a card for $100 on eBay. After their 13% final value fee and $5 shipping, you actually received about $82. If you paid $70 for that card, your profit is $12 — not $30. Those fees add up fast across dozens or hundreds of sales.
Tools for Tracking
A spreadsheet works. Seriously. Google Sheets, Excel, whatever you’re comfortable with. Make columns for each data point listed above. Update it after every transaction. It takes two minutes.
If you want something more automated, apps like CardLadder track card values and can help you monitor your collection’s worth over time. They’re not a tax tool specifically, but they’re useful for knowing where you stand.
Some people use eBay’s seller hub reports and download their sales data at the end of the year. That covers the sell side, but you still need to track what you paid for each card.
The key is consistency. Tracking everything in January and then forgetting about it until November doesn’t help. Make it a habit. Every purchase, every sale, two minutes in the spreadsheet.
Keeping Receipts
This is where people mess up. You bought a card on eBay for $45 six months ago. You sell it for $80. What did you pay for it? If you can’t prove the purchase price, the IRS could treat the entire $80 as income.
- Screenshot eBay purchase confirmations when you buy cards. Save them in a folder.
- Keep LCS receipts. Take a photo of them. Paper receipts fade.
- Save PayPal and bank statements that show card purchases.
- Card show purchases are the hardest to document. If you pay cash at a show, write it down immediately. Card, price, date, vendor if you know them.
You don’t need to be obsessive about it. But you do need enough documentation to reconstruct your cost basis if anyone ever asks.
End of Year: Calculating Actual Profit
When December rolls around, here’s the math:
Total sales (gross revenue from all platforms) Minus cost of goods (what you paid for the cards you sold) Minus platform fees (eBay fees, PayPal fees, etc.) Minus shipping costs (supplies and postage) Minus other expenses (top loaders, penny sleeves, mailers, printer labels)
What’s left is your actual profit. That’s the number that matters for taxes. For a lot of hobby sellers, the actual profit is way lower than the gross sales number that shows up on a 1099-K.
This is why tracking matters. Without records, you can’t deduct your costs, and you end up paying taxes on revenue instead of profit.
One More Thing
The founder of DisplayMyCard is a CPA, so yeah, we care about this stuff. The hobby is supposed to be fun. Taxes shouldn’t ruin it. But ignoring them doesn’t make them go away.
Set up a simple spreadsheet. Spend two minutes per transaction. Save your receipts. Talk to a tax professional if you’re doing any real volume. Future you will be glad you did.
Enhance Your Cards with AI
Remove backgrounds, add team designs, and make your cards look like they belong in a showcase. Free to try.
Try DisplayMyCard Free